Not The Squad: Rep. Elissa Slotkin and
her ‘Gang of 9’ offer Democrats a path of moderation
Date: August 5th, 2019
By: Ron Kampeas
Outlet: Jewish Telegraphic Agency
LANSING, Michigan (JTA)
— Tom Dalton could be the poster boy for Elissa Slotkin’s path to a second
term and, she would argue, to Democrats keeping the U.S. House of
The 67-year-old Vietnam navy vet routinely votes Republican — but
says he would not hesitate to vote for Slotkin, a Democrat, if he had the
“Seeing what’s happening today in the news, all you hear is
negative this and negative that, I would love to know if there’s a lot more of
what I saw today,” he said, after Slotkin and the Republican in the
neighboring district, Tim Walberg, thanked him for his military service at a
Veterans of Foreign Wars hall in this central Michigan town split between their
“I want to thank you for being a Republican and a Democrat,”
Dalton said, emphasizing the “you” after the duo gifted him with a
In an interview two days later, Slotkin told the Jewish Telegraphic
Agency that she sees bipartisanship as key to any success in Michigan, which
flipped to Trump in 2016 by a tiny margin. She was one of two Democrats to pick
up seats in the state last year, ousting the Republican incumbent in an upset.
“In my district, I have a very clear mandate to work across the
aisle,” she said. “It’s why I was sent to Washington.”
“My father was a Republican and my mother was a Democrat,” she
said. “In Michigan, we always fought about sports, not politics. The vitriol
from Washington has been imported in our swing state and people can’t stand
it. You saw how happy people are when people work together.”
Slotkin, a former CIA analyst, is one of nine veterans of the
national security apparatus who are freshman Democrats in Congress and who call
themselves the “Gang of Nine.” Three of them are Jewish: Slotkin, Elaine
Luria of Virginia, a Navy veteran, and Max Rose of Staten Island, an Army
The “Gang of Nine” contrast sharply with another
clique in the freshman Democratic class, “The Squad” of four
progressive congresswomen who include Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota and Rashida
Tlaib of Michigan. Although they wouldn’t describe themselves this way, you
might call them the “Anti-Squad,” freshmen whose security backgrounds and
moderation form an alternative to the progressives who have become symbols of
divides within the Democratic Party (and between the parties).
Slotkin speaks to Alan Caldwell at a Veterans of Foreign Wars post
in Lansing, Mich., July 30, 2019. (Ron Kampeas)Slotkin said both her national
security past and her Jewishness informed her emphasis on bipartisanship.
“You take an oath to defend the constitution,” she said, as a
CIA employee and in Congress. “Congress is the next chapter of our national
service. We pledged an oath to defend the constitution and that means working
together to make our constituents’ lives better.”
In Congress, Slotkin has built ties with Midwestern Republicans by
advancing Great Lakes region environmental improvement bills and has taken a
lead in championing typically Democratic issues, among them preventing foreign
influence in U.S. elections and protecting migrants at the southern border.
She is already well known in her caucus for her attention to
detail, in evidence at the VFW event, billed as a Veterans Resource Fair.
Slotkin listened intently to Martha Williams, who says her husband, who died
last month, was never adequately compensated for the sufferings he endured from
Agent Orange, an herbicide U.S. troops used in Vietnam. She instructed Williams
on how to fill in a request form. Asked if Slotkin was attentive, Williams
smiles and nods vigorously.
A few moments later, Slotkin tells the crowd that she has a special
pin for the spouses of Vietnam veterans and hands it to Williams, who tears up.
Another veteran, Alan Caldwell, pulled out a folder with clippings
about H.R. 303, a bill that would ensure that veterans get disability benefits
as well as retirement pay, initiated by Florida Republican Gus Bilirakis.
Slotkin asked for the clipping to remind herself to become a co-sponsor.
Caldwell was pleased.
“She done good!” he told a Slotkin aide.
Slotkin’s commitment to reaching across the aisle extended to
defending Jews from what she called a “precipitous rise” in anti-Semitism,
she said in the JTA interview.
“When we have a four-fold increase in violent anti-Semitic
attacks, people being killed in Poway and Pittsburgh, when cemeteries are being
abused and there are increasing threats to institutions, it’s important we
come together in a bipartisan way and are concerned about each and every
incident of anti-Semitism, of white supremacy,” Slotkin said. “Where people
are trying to split Americans from each other I want there desperately to be
In remarks recorded last weekend at a Detroit area fund-raiser for
Jewish Democrats, Slotkin appeared to skewer Republicans for talking about
anti-Semitism only to court Jewish support. Although the full context of her
remarks are not clear from the reporting by the Washington Free Beacon, a GOP
mouthpiece, Republicans pounced.
Said Slotkin: “We have, what I believe is a full-on attempt by
the Republican Party to grab a different community and bring them into the fold,
and I will just be very honest, right, they are not looking for our votes,
because we are a relatively small community, they are looking for our donors,
right? They are looking for our donors, and they are trying to sway us…”
Although it is clear that she has not finished her sentence, the
recording cuts off there.
“Congresswoman Slotkin should refrain from denigrating her fellow
Jews by saying that they are only wanted for their money,” the Republican
Jewish Coalition said.
Slotkin said the remarks were part of a broader critique of
attempts by Trump and the Republican party to depict Democrats as the sole
purveyors of anti-Semitism. Trump, for example, has repeatedly called the party
anti-Semitic and anti-Israel because of pronouncements, criticized by lawmakers
on both sides of the aisle, made by Omar and Tlaib.
“We need to be hyper-vigilant to focus on anyone who is
anti-Semitic, and we can’t pick and choose, and we shouldn’t let the Jewish
community be used as a pawn in the discussion,” Slotkin said.
Halie Soifer, the director of the Jewish Democratic Council of
America, defended Slotkin’s broader point.
“She is correct that Republican attempts to use anti-Semitism and
Israel as political wedge issues will fail at attracting Jewish voters,”
Slotkin, meanwhile, was among the Democrats who called on Omar to
apologize for a tweet suggesting Jewish money in the form of campaign
contributions had distorted U.S. Mideast policy.
“Rep. Omar’s comments traffic in age-old stereotypes and
anti-Semitic bias, drag down public conversation, and are counter to our
fundamental values of religious freedom and mutual respect,” she
said in a statement. “Elected officials must lead by example,
particularly now, and carry out their responsibility to unite rather than divide