‘Existing is Resisting’ Gaza Protest is Working
By Seth Frantzman
Middle East Forum
March 31, 2019
The one-year anniversary of the March of Return protests
began with weather that had the consistency of soup. Dust clogged the air, and
it threatened to rain. Nevertheless, the tens of thousands of Palestinian
protesters came anyway, driving up to five points along the Gaza security fence
to protest and riot.
Israel has become used to this over the last year. While
both Israel and Hamas – the main organizer of the protests – have altered
their tactics, Hamas's overall strategy has remained the same: to keep the
pressure up, looking to demonstrate its relevance after 12 years of failed rule
Hamas wants concessions. It wants attention. And it wants
martyrs – but not too many. This is the horrid calculus behind the squaring
off along the fence.
Israel's strategy is also clear: to stop any protesters or
rioters from crossing the border, and to prevent the protests from serving as a
cover for laying IEDs or sniper fire, or worse.
So far, both Israel and Hamas have been successful in their
respective strategies. While Hamas boasted last year that these marches would
lead to the "return," and that Palestinians would be celebrating the
conquest of Jerusalem, obviously they know this is impossible.
Yahya Sinwar, today the head of Hamas in Gaza having taken
over from Ismail Haniyeh in February 2017, spent 22 years in Israeli prisons.
Born in Khan Yunis in 1962, he knows exactly what he is up against. When he was
a young man in the 1980s, Gazans regularly commuted to jobs in Israel while
Israelis went to the coastal enclave to shop or for car repairs. Then the border
area was relaxed, exactly the opposite of today.
Sinwar was still in prison during Israel's unilateral
disengagement in 2005, and was repatriated to Gaza six years later as a result
of the 2011 Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange. The Gaza he returned to was ringed
with walls and fences, and blockaded on the Mediterranean by the Israeli Navy.
By 2011, Hamas was equipped with long-range rockets and was building better
ones, benefiting from smuggling via Sinai. Sinwar has watched as Israel
developed technological responses to the challenge of rockets and attack
The protests are a low-tech and asymmetric innovation by
Hamas to the realization that their technology cannot defeat Israel. Instead,
Hamas is promoting the concept of "existing is resisting," and samud,
or "steadfastness." That Hamas has been able to sustain the mass
protest for a year – initially every Friday and then on Tuesdays and also at
night – is a singular accomplishment among Palestinian factions. Yes, the
First and Second Intifadas were sustained. But the Gaza protests are unique
though they are rarely portrayed as such in the media because Gaza has become
less interesting amid the other crises of the region.
While the ongoing protests are not a global cause célèbre,
it's hard to gauge their importance for ordinary Gazans. Rare is the clan that
hasn't suffered a family member killed or wounded, many by live ammunition.
While some 260 dead may seem like a relatively small price for a year-long
protest, humanitarian medical NGOs working in Gaza have described their
difficulty treating the large numbers of the wounded.
On the Israeli side, Hamas's relative success can be seen
in the burned fields and forests, and the need to constantly close portions of
the border area as tensions escalate. The success can also be seen in shifting
Jerusalem's attention to the Gaza issue every few weeks when the Israeli
government has said it wants to concentrate on the Iranian threat in Syria. This
is no small accomplishment. Yet Israel has been smart enough – so far – not
to let herself be dragged into a fourth Gaza war. The number of rockets fired
from Gaza recently would have resulted in a war years ago. Before 2009 or 2012
or 2014, the trickle of rockets, mortars and other aggression led to conflict.
In 2018, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu outmaneuvered his political cohorts
to prevent a conflict.
Israel understands there are diminishing returns in
fighting in Gaza. Israel gains nothing. Hamas potentially can gain propaganda
points. And in the end, a ceasefire will likely result rather than regime
That doesn't mean that Israel is losing along the border.
In fact, Israel has shown through its constantly evolving military defense
technology just how she can outsmart Hamas. Using the latest sensors,
electro-optical imaging, drones and an array of other gadgets, Israel uses its
lethal precision weapons only as a last resort. Despite the complaints of human
rights groups or the United Nations – which might argue that Israel has used
excessive force, or that sniper fire should never be used against violent riots
– it appears Jerusalem has successfully ridden the learning curve of this
I went down on Saturday to witness the clashes unfold.
Unlike in the past, the cordon around the Gaza Strip prevented me and other
journalists from driving along back roads and dirt tracks to get closer to the
clashes. The IDF prefers that the media come to one lookout near Nahal Oz to
watch the conflict unfold. From the dusty fields in the south near Kerem Shalom,
surrounded by military vehicles, I heard flash bangs and shouting, along with
ambulance sirens screaming from the Palestinian side. A giant Palestinian flag
Further north near Kissufim, the same story unfolded. Here
too I saw the IDF's significant military presence, and the rings of Border
Police vehicles and cordons meant to distance civilians from the border. Iron
Dome batteries have also been deployed, and soldiers using Skylark drones were
positioning their metal birds in a field.
The relative quiet along the border is a testament to the
IDF's restraint. But the need to secure the border and the constant alert in
border communities is testament to what the Gazans have done.
No one wants this situation to continue forever. For now, it appears it will.