Trusting Iran to stop terrorism is like inviting an arsonist to
join the fire brigade
one of the world's most prolific sponsors of terrorism. How can we expect it to
stop once they have a nuclear deal?
By Dore Gold
July 10, 2015
foreign minister, Javad Zarif, has written
an op-ed in the Financial Times which sets forward a distinct sequence for
ostensibly resolving the daunting security challenges of the Middle East.
the P5+1 - the group of powerful nations negotiating with Iran - should
come to a deal over its nuclear program . As a result, he argues, Tehran
will "open new horizons" and join "the international battle"
against "the increasingly brutal extremism that is engulfing the Middle
idea that Iran is a partner in the fight against terrorism is not only
disingenuous but also absurd. What Zarif is seeking is a leap of faith by his
Western readers, who are asked to believe that a country which has been
repeatedly identified as the largest state supporter of terrorism in the world
will suddenly be altered by an agreement over its nuclear program into an ally
against terrorism. He is asking the world to simply trust Iran that this
transformation is about to happen.
is no evidence that the trust Zarif seeks is warranted in any way. Iran
operates globally through cells controlled by the Quds Force of the Islamic
Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), often backed by operatives of Hizbollah.
During the nuclear negotiations, this network has not been reduced in size; it
operates in some 30 countries and on five continents - Iranian-backed attacks
have taken place in such diverse locations as Argentina, France, Austria,
Bulgaria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, India, Thailand and even the United
in October, 2011, the US uncovered a plot by an IRGC operative to recruit
members of a Mexican drug cartel to conduct a mass casualty attack in Washington
DC aimed at the Saudi Ambassador to the US. Since that time IRGC activity
has only intensified. Yet another Iranian terrorist cell was discovered in Cypus
just last month.
in the West hope that since Iran is led by a Shiite government it can be
recruited in the fight against Sunni extremism, including
against the Islamic State (Isil) . This analysis often overlooks Iran's
proven willingness to cross the Sunni-Shiite divide to promote Sunni jihadism as
well. Just after 9/11, Sunni extremists, including al-Qaeda, fled Afghanistan
and sought asylum in Iran.
Musab al-Zarqawi, the future commander of al-Qaeda in Iraq, which eventually
became Isil. Iranian backing for Sunni jihadists, with arms and training, has
extended to Hamas and Islamic Jihad as well as to the Taliban in Afghanistan.
nuclear deal is likely only to intensify Iranian support for global terrorism
for two reasons.
of sanctions on Iran will result in a windfall of cash for the Iranian treasury,
which could reach $150 billion in the first year. As Iran decides which Middle
Eastern insurgency to back with its IRGC units, it often has to establish
priorities because it is operating under clear economic constraints.
constraints will be removed as Iran obtains the wherewithal to fully fund and
even expand its terrorist activity worldwide.
in past decades, states supporting terrorism feared retaliatory operations by
the West, such as the US attack on Libya in 1986. Deterrence could be created.
But if Iran becomes a nuclear threshold state, as a result of its impending
agreement with the P5+1, what are the chances that deterrence of this sort will
hold? Iran will seek to act with impunity as the terrorism it sponsors acquires
a protective nuclear umbrella.
is the last Iranian official who should talk about rejecting terrorism. Last
January, he paid a highly publicized visit to Lebanon and laid
a wreath at the grave of Imad Mughniyeh, the mastermind of Hizbollah
terrorism, who was responsible for the attacks in the 1980s on American and
French forces in Beirut, hijacking civilian aircrafts and taking international
Churchill has been attributed with the saying that he refused to be impartial
between the fire brigade and the fire. To take his distinction a step further,
depending on Iran to fight terrorism is like making an arsonist part of the fire
brigade. There is no basis for believing this will possibly work. Iran must
unequivocally abandon its backing of international terrorism if it ever wants to
rejoin the world community.
Dr. Gold is the Director-General of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel.